Ask The Dog Guy's

FREE Brain Drain Activity Guide For Your Dog

With your subscription to the 'Ask The Dog Guy' Newsletter (also FREE)
Brain Drain Offer Pop Up

Puppy Biting: Why Popular Advice Fails and What Actually Works

The short answerPuppy biting is a normal developmental behavior, but it becomes a problem when puppies aren’t taught clear boundaries early and consistently. Most advice fails because it focuses on managing the biting rather than teaching puppies how to control their mouths in real interactions. What works is addressing how puppies actually learn impulse control and social limits.

What almost never works

If you’ve been asking trainers, vet clinics, and scouring the Internet looking for solutions to your puppy’s relentless mouthing, nipping, and play biting and nothing has worked, I can almost guarantee it’s because you were advised to do what almost never works:

  • Redirect your puppy’s attention to a chew toy
  • Turn your back on your puppy
  • Ignore your puppy
  • Time-out your puppy
  • Reverse time-out your puppy
  • Pretend to be hurt by crying out (pretend?)
  • Blame overtiredness or overaroused states

Additionally,

  • You were quite possibly told that you mustn’t actually convey a clear cut, firm, but fair, “I’m not asking you, I’m telling you. Cut this out now!”, (something every dog, wolf, ape and human being has heard from time-to-time from a parent) or your puppy’s self-esteem would be ruined forever more.
  • You, (and everyone else told to stray from nature’s actual template) quickly discovered none of the aforementioned had meaningful impact.
  • You may have noticed that the solution(s) very often escalated the behavior
  • Now you may be worried that getting a puppy was a bad decision.
  • Alternatively you may be thinking that they sold you the one mentally deficient puppy.😄 Stubborn Dogs – Fact or Fallacy

Why it didn’t work (It’s not you, and it’s not your puppy)

Most dog trainers mean well with this sort of advice, but they’re often caught up in ideology that they’ve been told, and now tell others is life-skill science, when it’s far closer to teaching tricks-science. They’re not the same thing. In my experience, they and these ideas make up most of the dog training community. It is slowly, but steadily transitioning from ideology to legitimate behavior science and common sense more suited to teaching life skills than tricks. However, it’s easy for a puppy owner to find themselves subjected to cool sounding advice that ironically is based more on marketing and principles that don’t occur anywhere in the natural world when it comes to teaching and learning life-skills. This is a problem with “modern” puppy training, not with you or your dog.

This approach often uses terminology referencing variations on, “All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free/Never Say No/R+…’, treat, treat, treat” “science-based” training, and in many cases, crate training. Don’t get me wrong. They can point to science, albeit cherry-picked science perfect for teaching trick like behavior in non-fluid environments (training arena versus a regular home, yard, neighbourhood), rather than practical life skills like “Stay,” “Come,” and “Heel” – No Matter What. The same clarity and timing that fixes biting also matters in puppy potty training.

Things began to go south in the early to mid 80’s when cetacean trainers, more specifically Orca trainers started to show up at dog training conferences and writing books making:

What the orca trainers told dog trainers

  • Orcas (killer whales) can be taught entertaining behaviors that they wouldn’t independently do.
  • There are no leashes required.
  • The approach was described similarly (“All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free/Never Say No/R+…’, treat, treat, treat” “science-based”)
  • If such fantastic results could be achieved in this manner that ethically dog trainers should embrace the approach

The problem with these claims is that they conveniently leave out contradicting facts, and, or content that would otherwise require considerable modification of the claim (also known in formal logic circles as suppressed evidence or cherry picking).

Reality

  • The aquarium is the leash. Attempting to teach similar unnatural behaviors in a natural setting is extremely problematic.
  • The aquarium is unnaturally their entire world. Orcas are among the most socially complex non-human animals. Captivity severely reduces their social choices unnaturally impacting the focus on the person doing the training.
  • Food deprivation, where the trainer becomes the main gateway to food is by no means all positive or force free.
  • There is no science to support the approach for teaching life skills in natural settings. Tricks, yes. Life skills, no.
  • If the approach is as powerful as described why is it that there’s only one recorded incident of a wild orca injuring (but not killing) a surfer (1972), in spite of daily proximity to surfers, swimmers, kayakers, scuba divers, etc. Whereas “highly trained” captive orca incidents and fatalities are well documented. Captive orcas have killed four people, and many dozen have been seriously injured.
  • Unlike the average puppy and dog owner, people training captive killer whales do so as their full-time job, often with degrees in behavior.

Now consider the dogs you see in competitive obedience, something trainers that promote this ideology point to as “proof”. Yes, these dogs are, more often than not, trained using the “All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free/Never Say No/R+…’, treat, treat, treat” manner. Often, inarguably impressive on the surface. However, once the dog and handler leave the “theatre” where the “play” inaccurately called “obedience” was “performed,” cut the handler’s leash and steal their treats, and see what happens. 😄 For what it’s worth, I do use this approach when I’m teaching a dog tricks. It’s lots of fun, if done in moderation. You’ve probably witnessed, but not really thought about it, but I’ve found when this approach is overdone, the dogs involved are rarely calm. They often seem (around their owners) to be “jonesing”, much like an addict needing a fix.

For putting an end to puppy mouthing, nipping, and biting, not to mention teaching life skills such as “Stay,” “Come,” and “Heel” – No Matter What one must look at actually applicable areas of behavioural science such as, ethology, evolutionary biology, evolutionary psychology, anthropology, psychology (e.g. all four quadrants of operant conditioning – not the cherry picked version used by ideologically driven trainers) etc. These scientific disciplines provide far better clues as to how higher-order social species life skills are learned and taught when there isn’t a human around attempting to reinvent the wheel. It shouldn’t be a surprise that the concept of “No!”, is part of what happens in the real world.

Long story short, there’s nothing the matter with your puppy. There’s nothing the matter with you. The problem is with the approach. Whatever they want to call it, “All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free/Never Say No/R+…,” this is an approach to behavior that not a single higher-order social species on the planet embraces to teach their youngsters life skills, and I don’t know about you, but if my mother had embraced that ideology, I’d be dead or in jail. 😄

Then what is a puppy owner to do about puppy mouthing, nipping, and biting?

The hidden reasons that you must quickly discourage puppy mouthing, nipping, and biting.

Why all puppies mouth, nip and bite

Puppy mouthing, nipping and biting is nature’s way amongst litter mates, and with their mother of figuring out who respects who. The same goes with their human owners.

Once they get to a certain age puppies will play quite roughly with each other for pretty much 20 minutes out of every waking hour. They learn from this interaction who’s faster, stronger, more agile. Who’s more “driven”. A good part of that is learned through the use of their mouths (mouthing, nipping and biting each other). Their jaws might not be strong, but by 3 weeks of age their teeth have erupted and are sharp enough for each puppy to take notice and in time, figure out who they should be listening to, and who should be listening to them.

Interacting with mom has a similar benefit. If she is to do her job (teach life-skills), mother dogs have to teach their puppies who should be listening to who before the lessons can actually begin. For the first few weeks of life though, it’s all oxytocin driven interaction and a pup really can’t do too much that would elicit an “I’m not asking you, I’m telling you!”, response from their mothers. However, Mother Nature nudges a mother dog out of the love only mindset when pups are about 3 weeks of age. Still nursing, but now even more vigorously, with erupting teeth (razor blades) if she doesn’t put an immediate stop to how they are using their mouths, she’ll end up too lacerated to nurse, and so she introduces what I call her “Ugly Mom” side.😄

As much as ideological dog training concepts would like, mother dogs obviously can’t sit down with their puppies to talk about their feelings or provide encouragement to “Use your words next time.”, etc. When a pup uses its teeth too roughly when engaging with its mother, this is the catalyst for the first lesson that all puppies learn from their mothers. That lesson is that mother dogs will offer tone and body language not only to indicate love but also to warn their puppies that they’re not asking; they’re telling, “No!” Puppies that ignore the warnings are subjected to (gasp) some level of physical discipline in keeping with the puppy’s development, further motivating the pup to at all times consider their mother’s tone and body language. How they respond to being ignored varies, but it’s not unusual for a pup to find itself flattened with a mother’s paw, or find their heads surrounded firmly but fairly by her jaws, or even be on the receiving end of a nip. For what it’s worth, there’s no recorded instance of self-esteem being permanently ruined or the need for a lifetime of therapy. 😄 Mother dogs are certainly firm but fair and they’re never “all positive”, they’re almost always, positive.

When it’s more than play biting

Play biting isn’t the same as aggression. If your puppy freezes, stiffens or growls before biting, bites hard over food, toys or being handled, or you’re worried about children in the home, don’t wait for it to pass. You should book a free 15-minute Zoom pre-consult with me, so I can ask a few more questions and be sure I can help before you book a consultation.

Why for all puppy owners it’s critical that puppy mouthing, nipping and biting be addressed firmly, but fairly, and immediately

Well the obvious part is that who wants to live with an alligator? The less obvious is that Mother Nature put this behavior in place to save their mothers and you tons of time when it comes to actually teaching life skills like, “Stay,” “Come,” and “Heel” – No Matter What.

Follow ideology-driven training advice and you’ll end up with a puppy that thinks you’re at best a roommate and you’ll need to become a treat dispensing Pez Dispenser to influence your puppy’s “obedience”. For puppies that don’t learn from their nipping, and biting who’s the teacher and who’s the student, ultimately “Come” means, “If you have a minute, check your daytimer and whether I have treats.” “Stay” means, “Don’t move until I’m out of treats.” Walking with their dog ends up making one of their arms longer than the other. Ultimately, this affects the dog, its owners and every living being they cross paths with. It ends up being more of a “house arrest” lifestyle and probably not even close to what the average puppy owner has in mind for their puppy’s future. For some, the outcome is even more serious. (See the examples below.)

Bonus examples: what bad advice can cost

Here is a word-for-word quote from someone with a normal 9-week-old Rottweiler puppy, “She is not responding to correction. (correction as in redirection, not actual correction) She rag-dolled my 5-year-old child on the shoulder. She’s constantly herding people. When you yelp to let her know her bites hurt, instead of releasing, she goes harder. She picks up her food bowl and shakes it. My daughter is now scared of the dog.” Outcome: The dog returned to the breeder. This is a not uncommon outcome. Some dogs do end up returned to the breeder. However, some are surrendered to rescues.

I was once given a case study to review by a dog trainer intended for submission to prove her worth in a dog training ‘All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free’ certification process. The dog in her case study was a Golden Retriever, initially around ten weeks of age, and the dog owner was a single woman. Images showed the woman was covered in scabs from the puppy mouthing, nipping, and play biting and that her clothing paid a similar price. The trainer indicated that she had recommended that the woman do all of the ‘All Positive/Purely Positive/Force-Free’ strategies (redirect with a toy, time outs, crying out in pain, etc.) The trainer proudly indicated after only four weeks, the puppy’s mouthing, nipping, and play biting had (in her words) “extinguished.”

Question 1 for the trainer

If the puppy’s mouthing, nipping, and play biting had been directed towards its mother, how long would it have taken to “extinguish” the behavior? 30 days? Or, considering that any three or four-week-old puppy nursing vigorously with a mouthful of razor blades has the potential to lacerate its mother’s “nursing apparatus” enough to put future nursing in jeopardy, would it take mom four weeks to convey, “It’s not that I don’t love you, but right now, I’m not asking you, I’m telling you”. Even outside of nursing, most mother dogs will put up with a lot, but when they’ve had enough, every pup in the litter knows. Have these trainers never seen a mother dog “inform” her pups that their nursing days are over?

Question 2 for the trainer

If this dog’s owner had one or more young children, how many weeks into the four weeks of “training” would it have been before the average mother of young children was forced to return the pup to the breeder or surrender to a shelter? Ironically, what the above trainer attributed to successfully “extinguishing after 30 days” wasn’t really “evidence” that the approach worked. In my experience, almost all puppies where it isn’t correctly addressed outgrow the majority of mouthing, nipping, and play biting somewhere between 30 and 90 days. For them, the mission of who’s in charge has been accomplished. In the case of puppies “trained” in this way, they’ve learned who is the teacher (them) and who is the student (their owners), and as a result, real-world current and future life-skill obedience becomes much harder for the companion dog owners to teach.

There’s another type of training approach you must avoid

There are still trainers that subscribe to the ‘Might Is Right’, Alpha, Pack Leader, Dominant (Yank and Crank) ideology. This mindset and approach is how a bouncer alters the behavior of an unruly patron, and when used on puppies and dogs, it often gets the job done, but ends up with a submissive dog. The concepts of alpha, pack leader and dominant aren’t non-existent in the world of behavior, they’re just not the foundation of how you shape a youngster’s behavior. For example, you wouldn’t after your encounter with the bouncer confuse that approach with how you would modify the behavior of a youngster. Why “Being Alpha” Is a Terrible Way to Raise a Dog (Or A Kid)

Balanced/Fully Balanced/“Force-Free” etc.

I’ve encountered the term “balanced” in the dog-training world and, more often than not, discovered that it isn’t balanced in the holistic sense I associate with Nature’s Template. Too often, it’s simply another version of the “Might Is Right,” Alpha, Pack Leader, Dominance (“Yank and Crank”) ideology, but with some treats and praise thrown in.

That’s not what I mean, which is why I generally use the term fully-balanced.

In fully-balanced puppy training, lessons are structured to set the puppy up to succeed, not fail. Reward plays the predominant role, while force, when appropriate, is a relatively minor aspect of the approach. It takes the form of intelligent physical guidance or a means of obtaining a puppy’s attention so that the owner’s tone and body language can communicate the intended message. It is not used as a means of intimidation or punitive physical correction.

In fact, the way I train is, in essence, almost entirely positive. It’s just that I also include the concept of “No!”

At the other end of the spectrum are trainers who promote the all-positive approach, often marketed as “force-free.” Whether through a misunderstanding of what force actually is or the marketing appeal of the term, I believe it presents puppy owners with a misleading proposition.

Force-free is easy to say. It’s considerably harder to reconcile with the realities of raising a puppy and teaching everyday life skills.

The presence of force, by itself, doesn’t establish that its application is excessive or abusive.

Anyone who has ever tried to get a cranky toddler into a snowsuit or car seat has applied force without escalating to abuse. A breeze is a pleasant force; a hurricane is an excessive, unpleasant force. Both are examples of force.

The reality is that force is one of many parenting tools, and as is the case with all tools:

“The problem is rarely the tool, and more often the fool at the end of the tool.”

Puppy owners needn’t fear the responsible use of behaviour-modification tools in fully-balanced training, whether that involves intelligent physical guidance, obtaining a puppy’s attention, or, far more commonly, reward.

The critical distinction is understanding what you’re doing, why you’re doing it, and how to apply the appropriate tool without crossing the line into intimidation or abuse.

Problems arise when there’s a fool at either end of the dog-training spectrum: someone who doesn’t understand the difference between force and abuse, or someone whose ideology has convinced them that learning life’s necessary skills is an entirely all-positive journey.

Nature’s Template/Real Life

In order to put an end to puppy mouthing, nipping, and biting in a manner that is effective and still reasonable, you should stick with “Nature’s Template.” No species on the planet, dogs included, loses its self-esteem forever when measured discipline is applied, and there is no reason a puppy owner should have to wait until their puppy outgrows this distressing behavior, and there are several excellent reasons why they should not wait.

There are various ways to send an “I’m not asking you, I’m telling you” message to a puppy without undermining confidence or trust. I don’t make specific recommendations without meeting the owner and puppy directly, or on occasions where that isn’t possible, review some video examples of what the current situation is. The reason for this is which approach you choose depends on how long your puppy has been subjected to the redirection and similar advice, its age, its personality, and your handling ability. I also like to make sure that the pup’s unwanted behavior isn’t being exacerbated by insufficient mental and physical stimulation, too infrequent feedings (or nutritiously inferior food), all of which can be influenced both by the puppy’s current age and breed genetics.

Long story short, pick your puppy trainer wisely. It’s an unregulated industry. If you have questions, you should book a free 15-minute Zoom pre-consult with me, so I can ask a few more questions and be sure I can help before you book a consultation.

John “Ask The Dog Guy” Wade
35+ Years Experience | 170+ 5-Star Reviews

When the advice makes sense — but applying it feels uncertain…

If you’ve read this far, you likely recognize that puppy training that is actually going to make a positive difference in you and your puppy’s life shouldn’t be based on ideological concepts, and yet, pretty much everything you’re encountering in the unregulated world that is companion puppy and dog training is, when you think about it, pretty far from how any higher-order social species actually learns life skills from a loving authority figure.

If so, you’re now thinking about finding guidance that is actually based on long-established legitimate behavioral sciences, that aren’t based on bribery or bullying, that actually harnesses:

  • How your actual puppy sees the actual world we live in.
  • How twenty four hours a day, he or she makes connections that reveal to him or her, who will be the teacher and who will be the student, and this should be part of the training plan.
  • How to find a balance between being firm but fair.
  • How to create a learning environment that makes it easy to be all positive almost all the time.
  • Understanding that there will be times when it’s essential to be firm, and learning how to do so in a manner that’s in keeping with your puppy’s individual personality with an end result that succeeds in conveying that he or she isn’t bad, and you’re not bad, but not stopping a behavior would be bad.
  • How important it is to set reasonable age appropriate expectations for core life skills like “Stay,” “Come,” and “Heel” so you don’t set you or your puppy up to fail and can build on small successes until they’re “No Matter What”.

I work with companion dog owners locally and worldwide to translate sound scientific training principles into clear, practical next steps based on:

  • Your puppy’s age, temperament, genetics, and history
  • Your home environment and routines
  • Your short and long term wishlist (along with my recommendations)

The goal at this point isn’t usually more information. It’s clarity and direction.

Choose the type of help that fits your situation

Once you choose, you’ll answer a short set of questions so I can understand your puppy, your goals, and if you have them, your concerns before suggesting any next step. Nothing is booked automatically. No generic plans. No pressure.

Not ready for direct support yet?

If you prefer to continue learning independently, you can also explore:

•Practical training guides I’ve put together, (some free cheat sheets, 100’s of free articles) and eBooks

•Carefully selected tools and equipment for dogs giving their owners a physical run for their money.

•Ongoing education by email (newsletter – subscribe at page top (used sparingly, unsubscribe anytime)

John Wade seated with a golden retriever puppy. Invitation to request a free 15-minute phone or Zoom pre-training consultation using the form below.Puppy biting? You've tried redirecting, timeouts and ignoring it, but the biting continues. Ask The Dog Guy introduces another approach.Teaching a puppy a firm but fair No is an important part of establishing boundaries and communicating which behaviours are unacceptable.Learning No is part of Nature's Template. Young social animals learn boundaries as part of growing up.Teaching a puppy No does not require dominance, intimidation, fear or undermining the puppy's confidence.Same lesson, different puppies. Effective communication considers the individual puppy's personality and distinguishes correction from anger.

Free 15 minute Zoom or Phone Consultation About Your Puppy

More on puppies

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Leave a comment

2 thoughts on “Puppy Biting: Why Popular Advice Fails and What Actually Works”

  1. Mickayla Sijtsma

    Hi John!

    First of all, I must say I found your Youtube video by accident but I’m SO glad I found you. We’ve had our Rottweiler puppy for about 4 weeks, she is almost 12 weeks old. We’ve tried EVERYTHING the “All positive” trainers told us to do but she gets aggressive, bites even harder and really does act like she’s the teacher.

    Thanks a TON. For the first time in weeks I feel like I’m on the right track.

    Kind regards,

    Mickayla Sijtsma from The Netherlands

    1. Hi Mickayla,

      I’m sorry this sat so long without an answer. Thank you for writing, and I’m glad the article helped you feel you’re on the right track.

      What you describe is common. Biting that gets worse with redirecting and treats isn’t a puppy being bad. It’s a puppy who hasn’t yet been told, clearly, that biting people isn’t allowed.

      If you’d like help, you should book a free 15-minute Zoom pre-consult with me, so I can ask a few more questions and be sure I can help before you book a consultation. I coach owners by Zoom across Canada, the United States and overseas.

      Regards,

      John ‘Ask The Dog Guy’ Wade
      Embracing Science and Common Sense
      http://www.askthedogguy.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top